Who Are the Atheists in Indonesia? - Earlier this month, Alexander Aan was detained by the police in West Sumatra for writing, on his Facebook page, “God does not exist.” Alexander, who also administered an atheist group on the social networking site, declared that he does not believe in angels, devils, heaven and hell or other “myths.”
In short, he is an atheist.
I don’t know if Alex has done anything more to justify his arrest, but the incident made me ask why atheism is so frowned upon in Indonesia. Does a person who states that he does not believe in God actually offend religion? Is it only atheists who do not believe in God? Which God, anyway? There are, of course, many religions and many different gods.
For example, Muslims have their own holy book and their own God, each separate from that of Christians. Many Muslims and Christians would consider gods in the shape of an elephant or a monkey (the Hindu gods Ganesh and Hanuman) are nothing but myths. Presumably Hindus would not be happy if they had to worship Allah or Jesus Christ.
'Atheism does not violate Pancasila. All Indonesians may consciously and rationally choose their own beliefs. The country’s very foundation protects their right to do so.' (Photo courtesy of Karl Karnadi)
This means that if you ascribe to a certain religion, you will usually not believe in gods other than your own. In other words, religious people are atheists when it comes to the gods of other religions.
Even different denominations of the same religion can have different beliefs. Consider the two major communities of Islam in Indonesia, Muhammadiyah and Nahdlatul Ulama. NU believes that tahlil (saying prayers for the dead) is very Islamic since tahlil rituals are dhikr (remembering and honoring God). However, this has been deemed heretical by Muhammadiyah. Praise for God by one denomination can be considered the opposite by another.
Various Christian denominations also have their differences; Protestants and Catholics, for instance. Protestants do not pray to the Virgin Mary. The reason? They believe that the Bible states that Jesus is the only mediator between man and God. Here is the passage they often cite: “For there is one God, and one mediator between God and man, the man Christ Jesus” (1 Timothy 2:5). Thus, Protestants usually consider Catholics’ adoration of Mother Mary as idol worship.
On the other hand, Catholics believe that since God chose this woman to be the mother of Jesus, the respect Catholics pay to her is respect to God. Catholics are assured that in choosing a mother, the son of God has granted her a special place in their religion.
There are more examples of denominational difference, a crucial one of which is the belief in heaven and hell. Catholics believe that most people will eventually go to heaven after death. However, people not considered “decent” enough cannot just go straight to this wonderful place, but instead are first sent to purgatory — that is, a place for torture — until they are cleansed of their sins.
On the other hand, there is no purgatory in Protestantism. They only believe that people will go either to heaven or hell, nothing in between. Thus, even in the same religion, God seems to have different rules.
Indeed, one religion or even denomination can be considered heretical to others. If we talk about the world’s religions, can you imagine their differences? How many heavens, hells and varieties of gods are there?
Millennia ago, the polytheistic Romans were generally quite tolerant of other religions. They believed in many gods and often adopted other people’s gods. The belief in a single God, in fact, was considered odd for the inhabitants of the ancient Mediterranean. Consequently, many Greeks, Romans and Egyptians viewed the new religion of Christianity with suspicion.
In 64 CE, during the reign of the emperor Nero (37-68), a fire tore through Rome, lasting six days. In their anger, the people blamed their emperor for the tragedy. Nero quickly pointed his finger at the Christians, who were considered “atheists” for their worship of just one god. Nero ordered that these “atheists” be arrested and tortured.
Christians were the victims in that story, but they would go on to become the persecutors in another time. During the Crusades from the 11th to 13th century, Christians declared war on Muslims.
The point is, in different eras and in different places, various gods can be considered more genuine than others. Who is considered as atheist or not can also vary. One way or another, all of us can be considered atheists by people with differing belief systems. As self-declared atheist Stephen Roberts once said: “I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do.”( thejakartaglobe.com )
In short, he is an atheist.
I don’t know if Alex has done anything more to justify his arrest, but the incident made me ask why atheism is so frowned upon in Indonesia. Does a person who states that he does not believe in God actually offend religion? Is it only atheists who do not believe in God? Which God, anyway? There are, of course, many religions and many different gods.
For example, Muslims have their own holy book and their own God, each separate from that of Christians. Many Muslims and Christians would consider gods in the shape of an elephant or a monkey (the Hindu gods Ganesh and Hanuman) are nothing but myths. Presumably Hindus would not be happy if they had to worship Allah or Jesus Christ.
'Atheism does not violate Pancasila. All Indonesians may consciously and rationally choose their own beliefs. The country’s very foundation protects their right to do so.' (Photo courtesy of Karl Karnadi)
This means that if you ascribe to a certain religion, you will usually not believe in gods other than your own. In other words, religious people are atheists when it comes to the gods of other religions.
Even different denominations of the same religion can have different beliefs. Consider the two major communities of Islam in Indonesia, Muhammadiyah and Nahdlatul Ulama. NU believes that tahlil (saying prayers for the dead) is very Islamic since tahlil rituals are dhikr (remembering and honoring God). However, this has been deemed heretical by Muhammadiyah. Praise for God by one denomination can be considered the opposite by another.
Various Christian denominations also have their differences; Protestants and Catholics, for instance. Protestants do not pray to the Virgin Mary. The reason? They believe that the Bible states that Jesus is the only mediator between man and God. Here is the passage they often cite: “For there is one God, and one mediator between God and man, the man Christ Jesus” (1 Timothy 2:5). Thus, Protestants usually consider Catholics’ adoration of Mother Mary as idol worship.
On the other hand, Catholics believe that since God chose this woman to be the mother of Jesus, the respect Catholics pay to her is respect to God. Catholics are assured that in choosing a mother, the son of God has granted her a special place in their religion.
There are more examples of denominational difference, a crucial one of which is the belief in heaven and hell. Catholics believe that most people will eventually go to heaven after death. However, people not considered “decent” enough cannot just go straight to this wonderful place, but instead are first sent to purgatory — that is, a place for torture — until they are cleansed of their sins.
On the other hand, there is no purgatory in Protestantism. They only believe that people will go either to heaven or hell, nothing in between. Thus, even in the same religion, God seems to have different rules.
Indeed, one religion or even denomination can be considered heretical to others. If we talk about the world’s religions, can you imagine their differences? How many heavens, hells and varieties of gods are there?
Millennia ago, the polytheistic Romans were generally quite tolerant of other religions. They believed in many gods and often adopted other people’s gods. The belief in a single God, in fact, was considered odd for the inhabitants of the ancient Mediterranean. Consequently, many Greeks, Romans and Egyptians viewed the new religion of Christianity with suspicion.
In 64 CE, during the reign of the emperor Nero (37-68), a fire tore through Rome, lasting six days. In their anger, the people blamed their emperor for the tragedy. Nero quickly pointed his finger at the Christians, who were considered “atheists” for their worship of just one god. Nero ordered that these “atheists” be arrested and tortured.
Christians were the victims in that story, but they would go on to become the persecutors in another time. During the Crusades from the 11th to 13th century, Christians declared war on Muslims.
The point is, in different eras and in different places, various gods can be considered more genuine than others. Who is considered as atheist or not can also vary. One way or another, all of us can be considered atheists by people with differing belief systems. As self-declared atheist Stephen Roberts once said: “I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do.”( thejakartaglobe.com )
No comments:
Post a Comment